Essential oil adulteration is the addition, removal or substitution of material in an essential oil after distillation, so that the bottle no longer holds only what one plant made. Essential oils are adulterated in 8 ways, which run from dilution with a carrier oil to full reconstitution from synthetic chemicals and mislabelling of the species. The materials used are cheap fixed oils, colourless solvents such as dipropylene glycol, cheaper oils of a related species, natural isolates and synthetic copies of the oil's own main constituents. The 12 most faked oils are the rare and costly ones, with rose otto, melissa, sandalwood, lavender and frankincense at the top. Cheap sandalwood oil is not real because Santalum album heartwood takes 30 years or more to form oil, and a cheap bottle holds amyris, cedarwood or a synthetic sandalwood odorant. The supplementary part answers whether an adulterated oil is dangerous and how to avoid one.
How are essential oils adulterated?
Essential oils are adulterated in 8 ways, which are dilution with a fixed oil, dilution with a solvent, blending with a cheaper related oil, topping up with natural isolates, adding synthetic copies, full reconstitution, removal of fractions, and mislabelling the species or origin. Essential oil adulteration is any change to an oil after distillation that adds, removes or substitutes material. The definition follows from ISO 9235, which defines an essential oil as the product of distillation or pressing and nothing more. The purpose of adulteration is price, since every one of the 8 methods makes a costly oil cheaper to sell at the same label price.
The 8 ways are listed from the crudest to the hardest to detect.
- Dilution with a fixed oil. A carrier such as castor, cottonseed, fractionated coconut or mineral oil is added at 5% to 50%. The oil smells weaker and leaves a ring on paper.
- Dilution with a colourless solvent. Dipropylene glycol, diethyl phthalate, benzyl benzoate, isopropyl myristate or ethanol is added. The oil keeps its colour and clarity, and the solvent shows as a foreign peak on GC/MS.
- Blending with a cheaper oil of a related species. Lavandin is sold in or as lavender, cornmint as peppermint, clove leaf as clove bud, cassia as cinnamon bark and cananga as ylang ylang. The oil smells close to right, and a marker compound gives it away, such as camphor at 5% to 8% in lavandin against 0.5% at most in lavender.
- Topping up with natural isolates. Citral from may chang goes into melissa, geraniol from palmarosa into rose, linalool from ho wood into lavender and limonene from orange terpenes into lemon. The main constituent sits inside the reference range and the minor constituents fall.
- Adding synthetic nature-identical compounds. Synthetic linalool and linalyl acetate go into lavender and bergamot, synthetic menthol into peppermint, synthetic methyl salicylate into wintergreen and synthetic cinnamaldehyde into cinnamon. GC/MS cannot separate the synthetic from the natural molecule without chiral or isotope analysis.
- Full reconstitution. A "rose oil" is built from phenylethyl alcohol, citronellol, geraniol and nerol with no rose in it. The oil lacks the 100 or more minor constituents of the real oil.
- Removal of fractions. Terpenes are stripped from citrus oils, menthol is crystallised out of cornmint, or the first fraction of ylang ylang is sold and the rest is topped up. The oil is still plant material and no longer the whole oil.
- Mislabelling the species, origin or method. A hybrid lavender is labelled Lavandula angustifolia, Moroccan rose is labelled Bulgarian, or a solvent-extracted absolute is labelled steam-distilled. The bottle may be pure and is not what the label says.
Methods 1 and 2 are cutting, methods 3 to 5 are stretching, and methods 6 to 8 are faking. Method 3 is the most common in the lavender trade, and the camphor marker and the scent difference between the 2 plants are compared on the page about lavender versus lavandin oil.
What are essential oils cut with?
Essential oils are cut with 5 classes of material, which are fixed vegetable oils, colourless solvents, cheaper essential oils of a related species, natural isolates and synthetic aroma chemicals. The class chosen depends on the target oil. A thick dark oil such as patchouli hides a fixed oil. A thin clear oil such as lavender needs a colourless solvent or a cheaper related oil. The table below names the materials in each class, the oils they are most used in and the sign that reveals them.
| Class of cutting material | Examples | Oils most often cut with it | Sign on the report or in use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed vegetable oils | Castor, cottonseed, soybean, fractionated coconut, mineral oil | Patchouli, vetiver, sandalwood, frankincense, any oil sold "pre-diluted" without saying so | Oily ring on paper after 24 hours, higher specific gravity, triglyceride residue |
| Colourless solvents | Dipropylene glycol, diethyl phthalate, benzyl benzoate, isopropyl myristate, triacetin, ethanol | Lavender, rose, jasmine, sandalwood, ylang ylang, any fragrance oil sold as essential oil | Foreign peak on GC/MS, sticky or alcoholic feel, slow evaporation |
| Cheaper related essential oils | Lavandin, cornmint, clove leaf, cassia, cananga, Australian sandalwood, amyris, citronella, lemongrass | Lavender, peppermint, clove bud, cinnamon bark, ylang ylang, Indian sandalwood, melissa | Marker compound out of range, such as camphor, cassia's missing eugenol or lemongrass's missing sesquiterpenes |
| Natural isolates | Linalool from ho wood, geraniol from palmarosa, citral from may chang, limonene from orange terpenes, eugenol from clove leaf | Lavender, rose, melissa, lemon, cinnamon bark | Main constituent normal, minor constituents low, isotope ratio points to another plant |
| Synthetic aroma chemicals | Linalool, linalyl acetate, menthol, methyl salicylate, cinnamaldehyde, vanillin, benzyl acetate, phenylethyl alcohol | Lavender, bergamot, peppermint, wintergreen, cinnamon, vanilla, jasmine, rose | Racemic enantiomer ratio on chiral GC, no carbon-14, trace synthesis by-products |
The 5 classes line up with the first 5 of the 8 methods. Dipropylene glycol is the usual solvent because it is odourless, colourless and cheap, which is why it is the base of most fragrance oils. The line between a cut essential oil and a fragrance oil is crossed when the plant material falls below the synthetic material, and the 7 differences between the 2 products are set out on the page about fragrance oil versus essential oil.
Which essential oils are most often faked?
The essential oils most often faked are the 12 oils with the highest price and the simplest famous scent, which are rose otto, melissa, sandalwood, jasmine, neroli, helichrysum, frankincense, lavender, peppermint, lemon, wintergreen and cinnamon bark. Two forces select an oil for faking. A high price makes the gain large, which covers rose, melissa, sandalwood, jasmine, neroli and helichrysum. A high volume makes a small cut profitable across many bottles, which covers lavender, peppermint, lemon and frankincense. Wintergreen and cinnamon bark are faked because each is dominated by one cheap synthetic compound.
The 12 oils and their usual adulterant are listed below.
- Rose otto (Rosa damascena) is stretched with geraniol and citronellol from palmarosa, with phenylethyl alcohol, or with rose absolute, which shows as phenylethyl alcohol above 3% against 1% to 3% in true otto.
- Melissa (Melissa officinalis) is replaced with lemongrass or citronella, which shows as citral above 60% with no beta-caryophyllene, against geranial at 25% to 40% and beta-caryophyllene at 5% to 20% in true melissa.
- Sandalwood (Santalum album) is replaced with amyris, cedarwood, Australian sandalwood or synthetic sandalwood odorants, which shows as santalol below 41% or absent.
- Jasmine (Jasminum grandiflorum) is reconstituted from benzyl acetate, benzyl benzoate and indole, and any "jasmine essential oil" is a fake, since jasmine yields only an absolute or a CO2 extract.
- Neroli (Citrus aurantium flowers) is stretched with petitgrain and synthetic linalool and linalyl acetate.
- Helichrysum (Helichrysum italicum) is stretched with other Helichrysum species and synthetic neryl acetate, which shows as italidiones below 5%.
- Frankincense (Boswellia carterii and sacra) is stretched with turpentine or pine, which shows as high beta-pinene and camphene with no incensole acetate.
- Lavender (Lavandula angustifolia) is blended with lavandin or topped with synthetic linalool and linalyl acetate, which shows as camphor above 0.5% or a racemic linalool ratio.
- Peppermint (Mentha × piperita) is replaced with dementholised cornmint, which shows as menthofuran absent, against 1% to 9% in true peppermint.
- Lemon (Citrus limon) is stretched with distilled lemon terpenes, which shows as citral below 2% and no non-volatile waxes.
- Wintergreen (Gaultheria species) and sweet birch are replaced with synthetic methyl salicylate, which shows only on a carbon-14 test, since both oils are 96% to 99% methyl salicylate.
- Cinnamon bark (Cinnamomum verum) is replaced with cassia or synthetic cinnamaldehyde, which shows as eugenol below 2% against 2% to 13% in true bark oil.
Melissa is the clearest case of the price rule, because true melissa and lemongrass share a lemon scent and sit at opposite ends of the price range. The constituent profile and the safe use of the real oil are set out in the melissa essential oil profile.
Why is cheap sandalwood oil not real?
Cheap sandalwood oil is not real because the heartwood of Santalum album holds commercial oil only after 30 years or more of growth, the Indian harvest is controlled by the government, and the oil must carry 41% to 55% (Z)-alpha-santalol under ISO 3518, so a cheap bottle cannot have come from that tree.
The 4 substitutes sold as cheap sandalwood are these.
- Amyris (Amyris balsamifera), called West Indian sandalwood, is a Caribbean wood oil with no santalol, built on valerianol and elemol. Amyris is a legitimate oil under its own name and a fake under the name sandalwood.
- Australian sandalwood (Santalum spicatum) is a true Santalum species with 15% to 25% alpha-santalol and a drier, more resinous scent. Australian sandalwood is real sandalwood of a different species, and it is a fake only when labelled Santalum album.
- Cedarwood and copaiba are woody oils added to stretch any of the above.
- Synthetic sandalwood odorants, such as the trade materials Sandalore, Javanol, Ebanol and Polysantol, give the creamy sandalwood note in perfumery and contain no santalol. A "sandalwood essential oil" built on them is a fragrance oil.
Santalol is the test. Indian sandalwood shows 41% to 55% (Z)-alpha-santalol and 16% to 24% (Z)-beta-santalol. Hawaiian sandalwood (Santalum paniculatum) shows 40% or more alpha-santalol. What santalol is, why the 2 isomers matter and how the 3 true species compare are explained on the page about the santalol content of sandalwood oils. A true sandalwood of any species is bought with a GC/MS report that names the santalol percentage.
If adulteration is this common, which test catches each type?
Each type of adulteration is caught by one of 4 tests, which are GC/MS for added solvents, foreign oils and missing minor constituents, chiral GC for synthetic copies of chiral compounds, isotope ratio analysis for synthetic copies of non-chiral compounds and for origin, and physical constants for fixed oils. GC/MS is the first test and catches 5 of the 8 methods on its own. The table below matches the 8 methods with the test that catches each and the sign the analyst reads.
| Adulteration method | Test that catches it | Sign the analyst reads |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Dilution with a fixed oil | Specific gravity, paper test, GC/MS residue | Density above the ISO range, non-volatile residue, triglyceride signal |
| 2 Dilution with a solvent | GC/MS | Peak for dipropylene glycol, diethyl phthalate, benzyl benzoate or isopropyl myristate |
| 3 Blending with a related oil | GC/MS | Marker compound out of range, such as camphor in lavender or missing menthofuran in peppermint |
| 4 Topping up with natural isolates | GC/MS plus isotope ratio | Minor constituents low, carbon-13 or deuterium ratio points to another plant |
| 5 Adding synthetic copies | Chiral GC, carbon-14 | Racemic enantiomer ratio, no carbon-14 |
| 6 Full reconstitution | GC/MS | Fewer than 30 constituents, no trace compounds, round percentages |
| 7 Removal of fractions | GC/MS against the whole-oil standard | Monoterpenes below range in citrus, menthol below range in cornmint |
| 8 Mislabelling | GC/MS profile against the species standard, isotope ratio for origin | Profile matches another species or region |
GC/MS catches methods 2, 3, 6 and 7 alone, confirms method 1, and needs chiral or isotope support for methods 4, 5 and 8. What a GC/MS pass proves, what it cannot prove and when to ask for the extra tests are set out on the page about GC/MS tested oils.
Is an adulterated essential oil dangerous?
Yes, an adulterated essential oil can be dangerous, because the added material is undeclared, so the user cannot apply the dilution limits, allergen rules or child and pregnancy cautions that belong to it. Pure lavender is used at 1% to 3% on adult skin. An adulterated lavender with 20% synthetic linalyl acetate and 10% dipropylene glycol has no published limit. Three risks follow from the hidden material.
- Undeclared sensitisers. Added cinnamaldehyde, citral or oxidised limonene raise the chance of a skin reaction above the level the pure oil's limit assumes.
- Undeclared solvents. Diethyl phthalate is restricted in EU cosmetics, and dipropylene glycol is not meant for the lungs at diffuser concentrations.
- Wrong species. Lavandin sold as lavender, or cassia sold as cinnamon bark, carries a different camphor or cinnamaldehyde load and a different safety limit.
The reactions that an undeclared sensitiser causes, from irritation to sensitisation, are covered on the page about essential oil skin reactions.
How do you avoid adulterated essential oils?
You avoid adulterated essential oils by buying from a seller who publishes a GC/MS report for each batch, by reading the Latin name, chemotype, origin and method on the label, and by rejecting any rare oil priced like a common one. The 3 habits catch 7 of the 8 methods before the bottle is opened. A GC/MS report rules out solvents, related oils and reconstitution. The label rules out most mislabelling. The price rules out fake rose, melissa, sandalwood and jasmine.
The 3 habits belong to a longer list of 9 checks that work and 3 home tests that do not, which is set out in the parent guide on how to tell if an oil is pure. A rare oil deserves the full list every time, because the rare oils are the 12 most faked oils.
Rare and exotic essential oils from Miracle Botanicals
Miracle Botanicals sells about 200 single essential oils, each one steam-distilled, cold-pressed or CO2-extracted and tested by a third-party laboratory with GC/MS. The rare oils, including rose otto, melissa, neroli, helichrysum, agarwood and Hawaiian sandalwood (Santalum paniculatum), carry the same batch report as the common ones, and every product page names the Latin name, the plant part, the country of origin and the extraction method. Miracle Botanicals is based in Hawaii and distils a small number of island oils and hydrosols. Browse the rare and exotic essential oils collection to compare the oils most often faked elsewhere, each with its santalol, citral or citronellol percentage on request.




