THE MIRACLE BOTANICALS JOURNAL

Frankincense Essential Oil Species: Chemistry, Scent and Uses

Frankincense carterii and sacra are 30% to 65% alpha-pinene, serrata 50% to 61% alpha-thujene. Compare scent, uses, safety and price of 5 species.

Illustration of five dishes of frankincense resin tears in different shades beside five amber bottles

Frankincense essential oil is steam distilled from the dried resin of 5 main Boswellia species, which are carterii, sacra, serrata, frereana and papyrifera. The difference between the 5 oils is the main constituent, with alpha-pinene leading in carterii and sacra, alpha-thujene in serrata, a mix of both in frereana and octyl acetate in papyrifera. Every species is diluted to 1% to 3% for adult skin, which is 6 to 18 drops in 30 mL of carrier oil. The sections below define the 5 species, settle the carterii and sacra naming debate, rank the species for scent and diffusing, and set out safety, price and sustainability. The supplementary part answers what frankincense neglecta is and how to tell which species is in a bottle.

What is the difference between carterii, sacra, serrata, frereana and papyrifera frankincense?

The difference between carterii, sacra, serrata, frereana and papyrifera frankincense is the main constituent of each oil, with alpha-pinene leading in carterii and sacra, alpha-thujene in serrata, a mix of both in frereana and octyl acetate in papyrifera, according to published GC/MS analyses of the 5 oils. The difference between frankincense and frankincense serrata follows from this, because a bottle labelled only "frankincense" usually holds carterii or sacra oil, and serrata is the Indian species at 50% to 61% alpha-thujene.

Frankincense carterii essential oil is an essential oil steam distilled from the dried resin of Boswellia carterii Birdw., a tree of northern Somalia. Frankincense carterii oil smells sweet, resinous and slightly lemony. The main constituent of frankincense carterii oil is alpha-pinene at 30% to 65%, with limonene and myrcene next.

Frankincense sacra essential oil is an essential oil steam distilled from the dried resin of Boswellia sacra Flück., the tree of Dhofar in southern Oman and of eastern Yemen. Frankincense sacra oil smells bright, dry and piney, with a citrus lift. The main constituent of frankincense sacra oil is alpha-pinene at 40% to 65%, with limonene next.

Frankincense serrata essential oil is an essential oil steam distilled from the dried resin of Boswellia serrata Roxb. ex Colebr., the Indian frankincense of the dry forests of central and western India. Frankincense serrata oil smells fresh, green and citrus-resinous. The main constituents of frankincense serrata oil are alpha-thujene at 50% to 61% and alpha-pinene at 5% to 13%.

Frankincense frereana essential oil is an essential oil steam distilled from the dried resin of Boswellia frereana Birdw., a tree rooted in the limestone cliffs of northern Somalia. Frankincense frereana oil smells clean, lemony and lightly piney. The main constituents of frankincense frereana oil are alpha-pinene at 20% to 45% and alpha-thujene at 25% to 40%.

Frankincense papyrifera essential oil is an essential oil steam distilled from the dried resin of Boswellia papyrifera (Caill. ex Delile) Hochst., a tree of the dry woodlands of Ethiopia, Eritrea and Sudan. Frankincense papyrifera oil smells sweet, fruity and soft. The main constituent of frankincense papyrifera oil is octyl acetate at 50% to 60%, an ester that marks the species.

The table below places the 5 oils side by side on the 9 attributes that separate them on a GC/MS report and in the bottle.

Attribute Carterii Sacra Serrata Frereana Papyrifera
Latin name Boswellia carterii Birdw. Boswellia sacra Flück. Boswellia serrata Roxb. ex Colebr. Boswellia frereana Birdw. Boswellia papyrifera (Caill. ex Delile) Hochst.
Main origin Northern Somalia Oman (Dhofar), Yemen Central and western India Northern Somalia Ethiopia, Eritrea, Sudan
Plant part and method Resin, steam distilled Resin, steam distilled Resin, steam distilled Resin, steam distilled Resin, steam distilled
Main constituent Alpha-pinene 30% to 65% Alpha-pinene 40% to 65% Alpha-thujene 50% to 61% Alpha-pinene 20% to 45% Octyl acetate 50% to 60%
Marker that separates it Alpha-thujene under 10% Alpha-pinene enantiomer ratio (chiral GC/MS) Alpha-pinene only 5% to 13% Alpha-thujene 25% to 40% Octyl acetate and octanol
Scent Sweet, resinous, slightly lemony Bright, dry, piney, citrus lift Fresh, green, citrus-resinous Clean, lemony, lightly piney Sweet, fruity, soft
Main uses Diffusing, meditation, face oil Perfume, diffusing, meditation Everyday diffusing, massage Daytime diffusing, light perfume Evening diffusing, perfume
Safety note Oxidises; fresh oil for skin Oxidises; fresh oil for skin Alpha-thujene is not thujone Alpha-thujene is not thujone Ester-led; slower to oxidise
Price and sustainability Mid price; over-tapping concerns Highest price; IUCN Near Threatened Lowest price High price; small cliff harvest Lower price; wild stands projected to halve in 20 years

None of the 5 oils contains boswellic acids, because these resin triterpenes are too heavy to distil. Frankincense as a single oil, with its benefits, blends and dilution, is covered on the frankincense essential oil profile. Carterii and sacra, the closest pair, come next.

How does frankincense carterii differ from sacra?

Frankincense carterii differs from sacra mainly in origin and name, with carterii from Somalia and sacra from Oman and Yemen, while both oils are led by alpha-pinene, at 30% to 65% in carterii and 40% to 65% in sacra. Boswellia sacra was described by Flückiger in 1867, and Boswellia carterii was described by Birdwood in 1870. Thulin and Warfa's 1987 revision of the frankincense trees of northern Somalia and southern Arabia, in the Kew Bulletin, treated carterii as a synonym of sacra, and Kew's Plants of the World Online follows that ruling. The trade keeps both names, so on a label carterii signals Somali resin and sacra signals Omani or Yemeni resin.

A 2012 study by Woolley and colleagues in the Journal of Chromatography A separated carterii and sacra oils by the ratio of the 2 mirror-image forms of alpha-pinene, measured with chiral GC/MS, while a standard report shows the 2 oils as near twins. Sacra smells brighter and drier than carterii. The naming problem runs deeper in Somaliland, where resin traded as carterii, with an oil dominated by 1-methoxydecane, proved to come from Boswellia occulta, a tree described by Thulin, DeCarlo and Johnson in Phytotaxa in 2019. A standard report cannot settle every species question, and the limits of GC/MS testing explain when a chiral test is needed.

How does frankincense frereana differ from carterii?

Frankincense frereana differs from carterii in its constituents, with frereana at 25% to 40% alpha-thujene beside 20% to 45% alpha-pinene, where carterii is led by 30% to 65% alpha-pinene with alpha-thujene under 10%. Boswellia frereana roots in bare limestone cliffs, and its pale resin, sold under the Somali name maydi, is chewed as a gum in the Arabian Peninsula. Carterii resin holds boswellic acids and frereana resin holds none, a difference that stops at the resin because neither oil carries them. Frankincense frereana oil smells lighter and more lemony than carterii, and the small cliff harvest makes frereana the dearer oil. The resin tears of both species, with their grades and colours, are compared on the page about frankincense resin tear grades.

Which frankincense species smells best?

The frankincense species that smells best as a classic frankincense is carterii, because its sweet, resinous and lemony balance is the reference olibanum note in perfumery. The other 4 species move the scent in 4 directions from that reference.

  • Brighter. Frankincense sacra smells drier and more piney, and Hojari, the top grade of Omani sacra resin, is the most prized frankincense in Oman.
  • Lighter. Frankincense frereana smells cleaner and more lemony, with the least heaviness of the 5.
  • Greener. Frankincense serrata smells more citrus-like, because alpha-thujene replaces most of the alpha-pinene.
  • Sweeter. Frankincense papyrifera smells fruity, because octyl acetate is an ester with an orange-like, waxy note.

Somali carterii and Indian serrata are compared peak by peak on the page about carterii vs serrata frankincense. Scent decides the diffuser choice, ranked next.

Which frankincense species is best for diffusing?

Frankincense carterii is the best species for everyday diffusing, because its 30% to 65% alpha-pinene evaporates fast and scents a room within minutes at 3 to 5 drops per 100 mL of water, with frereana second for a lighter daytime scent. Frankincense papyrifera suits evening and meditation, because octyl acetate evaporates more slowly than alpha-pinene. Frankincense serrata suits daily diffusing at the lowest cost, and sacra gives the brightest scent at the highest price. No published trial compares the 5 species in a diffuser, so the ranking rests on chemistry and scent. Every species runs 30 to 60 minutes, then pauses as long, and the drop counts for every tank size are on the page about diffuser drops and timing.

Are all frankincense species safe?

Yes, all 5 frankincense species are safe for adults at 1% to 3% on skin, which is 6 to 18 drops in 30 mL (1 oz) of carrier oil, and Tisserand and Young's Essential Oil Safety (2014) lists no contraindications for frankincense oil.

What are the safety and precautions for the 5 frankincense species?

The 5 frankincense species share 5 safety precautions, which are oxidation, pregnancy, children, pets and swallowing, and none of the 5 is phototoxic or carries a dermal maximum in Tisserand and Young (2014).

  1. Oxidation. Oxidised alpha-pinene and limonene sensitise skin, so a bottle older than 3 years goes into a diffuser and not onto skin.
  2. Pregnancy. Frankincense at 1% is one of the oils most aromatherapists accept after the first trimester, with no species preferred.
  3. Children. Children aged 2 to 6 use at most 1%, which is 6 drops in 30 mL, and babies under 2 get a hydrosol instead of the oil.
  4. Pets. Frankincense is not on the ASPCA list of oils most hazardous to cats, and diffusion happens in a room a dog can leave and only in a room a cat cannot enter.
  5. Swallowing. A person who swallows an essential oil contacts Poison Control (1-800-222-1222 in the United States) without inducing vomiting.

The 25% to 61% alpha-thujene in serrata and frereana is a monoterpene hydrocarbon, unrelated to thujone, the neurotoxic ketone of sage and wormwood, so neither oil carries a thujone limit. A patch test on the inner forearm, read after 24 hours, comes before first skin use. The gentlest product for babies and for rooms shared with cats is the hydrosol, at about 0.02% to 0.05% dissolved oil, and the species waters are compared on the page about frankincense hydrosol by species.

How do frankincense species differ in price and sustainability?

Frankincense species differ in price and sustainability by tree and origin, with sacra and frereana the highest-priced oils, serrata the lowest, and papyrifera under the clearest documented threat, according to a 2019 study by Bongers and colleagues in Nature Sustainability that projected wild papyrifera populations to halve within 20 years. Over-tapping, grazing, fire and insect attack stop young papyrifera trees from replacing old ones. Boswellia sacra is listed as Near Threatened on the IUCN Red List. No Boswellia species is listed in the CITES appendices, so the trade needs no CITES permit, and sustainability rests on harvest practice and traceability. Over-tapping, meaning more cuts per tree and shorter rests than tradition allows, is the main concern for the Somali carterii and frereana trees.

A sustainable purchase names the species, country, harvest method and batch, and wild resin can be certified organic under the USDA wild-crop rule, 7 CFR 205.207. The reasons one oil costs many times another are set out on the page about why essential oil prices vary.

Which frankincense species should you buy for your purpose?

You should buy frankincense carterii for a classic scent and everyday diffusing, frereana for light daytime diffusing, papyrifera for evening blends and perfume, serrata for use on a budget, and sacra for the brightest scent, at 1% for the face and 2% for the body. The table below matches 7 purposes to the species that suits each and names the reason.

Purpose Species to choose Reason
Classic frankincense scent and meditation Carterii Reference olibanum note; alpha-pinene 30% to 65%
Everyday diffusing Carterii Fast-evaporating alpha-pinene at a mid price
Light daytime diffusing at work or study Frereana Clean, lemony mix of alpha-pinene and alpha-thujene
Evening blends and natural perfume Papyrifera Sweet octyl acetate that evaporates slowly
Diffusing and massage on a budget Serrata Lowest price; fresh alpha-thujene scent
Brightest scent for special occasions Sacra Bright, dry, piney top note
Face oil at 1% Carterii or sacra, from a fresh bottle No species is proven better for skin; freshness matters more

No published trial compares the 5 species on skin, sleep or mood, so the choice rests on chemistry, scent, price and sourcing. Frankincense has been smelled during prayer and meditation for at least 3,000 years, and the breathing practice that goes with it is set out in the guide on how to meditate with essential oils. The remaining sections answer what frankincense neglecta is and how to tell which species is in a bottle.

What is frankincense neglecta?

Frankincense neglecta essential oil is an essential oil steam distilled from the dark resin of Boswellia neglecta S.Moore, a sixth species from the dry bushland of Kenya, Ethiopia and Somalia, sold as black frankincense. Frankincense neglecta oil smells sharp, piney and peppery. The main constituent of frankincense neglecta oil is alpha-pinene, and published GC/MS analyses are too few to set a reliable range. Boswellia rivae, from Ethiopia and Kenya, is a seventh species sold by specialist distillers. The neglecta harvest, scent and uses are described on the frankincense neglecta profile.

How do you tell which frankincense species is in a bottle?

You tell which frankincense species is in a bottle by reading the Latin name on the label and matching the batch GC/MS report to the species marker, which is alpha-pinene for carterii and sacra, alpha-thujene above 50% for serrata, a pinene and thujene mix for frereana, and octyl acetate for papyrifera. A carterii oil cut with cheaper serrata shows alpha-thujene above 10%. A report led by 1-methoxydecane points to Boswellia occulta, whatever the label says. The 4 marks of a pure oil are set out in the guide on how to choose and test pure essential oils, the parent page for every species compared here.

Frankincense essential oils from Miracle Botanicals

Miracle Botanicals sells carterii, sacra, serrata, frereana, papyrifera, neglecta and rivae frankincense essential oils, each tested by a third-party laboratory with GC/MS, beside CO2 extracts, hydrosols, resin tears and sampler sets. Every product page names the Latin name, plant part, origin and extraction method, and the batch GC/MS report is available on request. Browse all frankincense products to compare the species by scent, main constituent and price.

Hope Johnson, founder of Miracle Botanicals

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Hope Johnson

Founder, Miracle Botanicals

Hope Johnson founded Miracle Botanicals with her family in Hawaiʻi in 2011. She shares her experience with essential oils and aromatic rituals through the journal and continues to support the family business as a consultant.

Read more about author

KEEP EXPLORING

Related articles

LET’S STAY CONNECTED

A little inspiration, delivered.

Subscribe to get special offers, free giveaways, and once-in-a-lifetime deals.

Read our Privacy Policy.