THE MIRACLE BOTANICALS JOURNAL

How to Buy Pure Essential Oils: Quality, Safety and Price

Buying pure essential oils comes down to 5 decisions: the oil, seller, size, price per mL and storage. Check the label and batch GC/MS report first.

Illustration of hands inspecting an essential oil bottle beside a checklist before buying

Buying pure essential oils comes down to 5 decisions made in order, which are the oil, the seller, the size, the price per mL and the storage. The oil is fixed by its Latin name, plant part, chemotype, origin and extraction method, and by the safety limits of the people and pets who will meet it. The seller is chosen by one document, a batch GC/MS report from a named third-party laboratory with a lot number that matches the bottle. The price is compared per mL for the same Latin name, origin and method, and the size is matched to how fast the oil is used before it oxidises. The sections below set out the 5 decisions, the safety checks, a 9-row label checklist, where to buy, how to judge an essential oil company and how to compare prices. The supplementary part answers how to check a bottle when it arrives, how to store it, and how the buyer's checklist relates to the purity checks.

How do you buy pure essential oils?

You buy pure essential oils by making 5 decisions in order, which are the oil, the seller, the size, the price per mL and the storage, and by reading the label and the batch GC/MS report before you pay. Each decision narrows the next one. The oil decision fixes what the seller must prove, and the seller's proof makes the price comparable.

The 5 decisions run in this order.

  1. Choose the oil by Latin name, plant part, chemotype, origin and extraction method, and check its safety limits for every person and pet in the home.
  2. Choose the seller by its batch GC/MS report, its label and its claims.
  3. Choose the size by how many drops a week the oil will be used and how long it keeps after opening.
  4. Compare the price per mL with the same oil from other sellers and with the plant's yield.
  5. Store the bottle cool, dark and capped from the day it arrives.

No decision on the list depends on a grade word, because no official grade system exists for essential oils sold for aromatherapy, and what each grade label does and does not mean is set out on the page with essential oil grades explained. The first decision, the oil, shapes every decision after it.

How do you choose a good essential oil?

You choose a good essential oil by fixing 5 botanical facts before you look at any brand, which are the Latin name, the plant part, the chemotype, the country of origin and the extraction method, and then by matching the oil's main constituent to the purpose. A common name can cover several oils. "Eucalyptus" covers Eucalyptus globulus at 65% to 85% 1,8-cineole, Eucalyptus radiata at 60% to 75%, and lemon eucalyptus (Corymbia citriodora) at under 1% 1,8-cineole with 65% to 85% citronellal. "Lavender" covers true lavender (Lavandula angustifolia) and lavandin, a cheaper hybrid with more camphor.

The extraction method and the chemotype change the oil in the bottle. Cold-pressed lime oil is phototoxic, and steam-distilled lime oil is not. Rosemary comes in cineole, camphor and verbenone chemotypes, each with a different main compound and a different safety limit, as the page about essential oil chemotypes explains. The purpose then picks the oil, such as linalool-rich lavender for winding down, menthol-rich peppermint for a cooling scent and terpinen-4-ol-rich tea tree for skin care. The people who will use the oil set the last filter.

Which safety checks come before you buy an essential oil?

The safety checks that come before you buy an essential oil are 5 questions about who and what the oil will meet, which are children, pregnancy, cats, sun exposure and sensitive skin, answered from the limits in Tisserand and Young's Essential Oil Safety (2014). A buyer runs the 5 checks before choosing a bottle, because an oil that fails one of them stays off the list for that home.

The 5 safety checks set these limits.

  • Children. Peppermint oil is not used on or near the face of children under 3, and 1,8-cineole-rich oils, such as eucalyptus globulus and rosemary cineole, are not used near the face of children under 10.
  • Pregnancy. Wintergreen, pennyroyal, sage, wormwood and camphor-rich oils are avoided throughout pregnancy.
  • Cats. Tea tree, peppermint, eucalyptus, cinnamon, clove, pine, ylang ylang and citrus oils are hazardous to cats, according to the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center.
  • Sun exposure. Cold-pressed bergamot is limited to 0.4% on skin, expressed lime to 0.7% and expressed lemon to 2% before sun exposure, while bergamot FCF and steam-distilled lime carry no limit.
  • Sensitive skin. Cinnamon bark and clove bud carry skin maximums below 1%, at 0.07% for cinnamon bark and 0.5% for clove bud.

Packaging is part of the safety check. In the United States, a liquid with more than 5% methyl salicylate, such as wintergreen oil, must be sold in child-resistant packaging under the Poison Prevention Packaging Act. A carrier oil belongs in the same order, since adult skin use at 1% to 3% is 6 to 18 drops of essential oil in 30 mL of carrier. The 7 rules for skin, diffusers and family use are set out in the essential oil safety rules.

What should you look for when buying essential oils?

The 9 things to look for when buying essential oils sit on the label, the bottle and the product page, and the batch GC/MS report from a named third-party laboratory is the one that proves the other 8. The table below gives each check with a passing and a failing example.

Check Passes Fails
1 Latin name and plant part Lavandula angustifolia, flowers "Lavender oil" with no species
2 Chemotype, where one exists Rosemary ct. cineole "Rosemary oil" with no chemotype
3 Origin and extraction method Bulgaria, steam-distilled No country and no method
4 Batch number and date Lot number with a distillation or bottling date No lot number
5 GC/MS report Batch-specific, from a named third-party laboratory "Typical analysis" with no batch number
6 Bottle Amber or cobalt glass with an orifice reducer and a tamper seal Clear glass, plastic, or a rubber dropper fitted for storage
7 Claims Aroma and use descriptions only Disease claims on the page or the box
8 Grade words None, or backed by a named standard such as ISO 3515 "Therapeutic" or "Grade A" in place of a report
9 Price Follows the plant's yield across the range One price for rose, sandalwood and sweet orange

Rows 1 to 5 trace the bottle to a report, rows 6 and 7 protect the oil and the buyer, and rows 8 and 9 test the seller's honesty. A bottle that fails any of rows 1 to 5 cannot be tied to a report, and the check stops there. The 10 signs that separate a good oil from a poor one, including whether a dark bottle means quality, are set out on the page about the signs of a high-quality oil. The seller who supplies those facts is the next decision.

Where should you buy pure essential oils?

You should buy pure essential oils where you can read the batch GC/MS report and the full botanical label before you pay, which in practice means a specialist retailer or a distiller that publishes reports on its product pages or sends them on request. The place of purchase decides what can be checked. A product page can hold a report, and a shop shelf holds only a label.

The table below compares 5 places to buy on what the buyer can check before paying and the main risk at each.

Where you buy What you can check before paying Main risk
Specialist retailer or distiller, online Full label on the product page; batch report online or on request A large range can mix strong and weak oils, so the report is read oil by oil
Online marketplace Listing text and photos Mislabelled fragrance oils, no batch report, and a listing that can change seller
Multi-level marketing distributor Company label and in-house test claims Commissions in the price and health claims from distributors
Natural products shop The physical bottle and a tester Testers oxidise on an open shelf, and staff rarely hold the report
Pharmacy, supermarket or home store The label and the ingredient list "Aromatherapy oil" products can be blends or carrier dilutions

Online buying gives the buyer the report, and shop buying gives the buyer the scent, so the strongest route is a seller who publishes the report and sells small sizes that let the scent be tried at low cost. A report is evidence of composition, not of everything, and what the test covers and misses is set out on the page about what a GC/MS test proves.

What is the best essential oil company?

The best essential oil company is the one that answers the buyer's checklist in writing for the oil you are buying, and no independent body ranks essential oil companies, so every "best company" list is the opinion of a seller, an affiliate or a distributor. A company can be the best source for one oil and a weak source for another, because each oil comes from a different distiller, country and harvest. A seller of lavender from its own farm can buy frankincense from a broker. The fair test runs per oil and per batch, read from the report.

The specialist retailer or distiller answers the checklist best on average, and sellers of every size exist in that group. The 10 questions that separate one brand from another, from the Latin name to the sales model, are set out in the guide to choosing an essential oil brand. Once the seller is chosen, the price and the size remain.

How much should you pay for pure essential oils?

You should pay a price per mL that matches other sellers of the same Latin name, origin and method, and that price rises with the plant's yield, so rose otto, melissa and sandalwood cost many times more than sweet orange or lemon. Price per mL is the only fair unit, because bottle sizes differ from 2 mL to 30 mL and more.

The size decision comes before the price comparison. One mL holds about 20 drops, so a 10 mL bottle holds about 200 drops and lasts 6 to 10 weeks at 3 to 5 drops a day. Opened citrus and conifer oils keep 6 to 12 months and most herb and flower oils 1 to 2 years, so a large bottle of lemon oil used once a week oxidises before it empties. A diluted rare oil is compared by the oil it holds. A 10 mL roller of rose otto at 3% in jojoba holds 0.3 mL of rose otto, so its price per mL of rose is the bottle price divided by 0.3.

Price carries information at the low end. Rose otto, melissa, neroli and sandalwood need hundreds or thousands of kilograms of plant material per kilogram of oil, so an oil of those names priced like lavender is diluted, blended or synthetic. A high price proves nothing on its own. The yield, labour and sales costs behind each oil's price are compared on the page about cheap vs expensive oils. With the oil, seller, size and price fixed, the checklist can be turned on the sellers themselves.

Once you have a checklist, which brands and shops pass it?

The brands and shops that pass the buyer's checklist are the ones that answer all 5 decisions in writing before payment, with a batch GC/MS report, a full botanical label, a price that follows the plant and no disease claims. A pass is decided per oil, so one shop can pass for lavender and fail for sandalwood. Four signs fail a seller at once, and each one is visible before the sale.

  • The seller lists an oil that no plant yields, such as lilac, gardenia or honeysuckle essential oil.
  • The seller prices every oil the same, from sweet orange to rose.
  • The product pages carry no Latin names, no origins and no batch numbers.
  • The seller offers a grade word or a member price in place of a report.

A seller of fragrance oils under plant names fails the first sign, and the label words that tell the 2 products apart are set out in the comparison of fragrance oil versus essential oil. A seller that passes still ships a bottle that needs checking, which is where the remaining questions begin.

How do you check an essential oil when it arrives?

You check an essential oil when it arrives in 5 steps, which are inspecting the seal and the bottle, matching the batch number with the GC/MS report, reading the label against the order, smelling a drop on a blotter, and writing the opening date on the label. A bottle that fails a step is reported to the seller before it is used.

The 5 steps run in this order.

  1. Inspect the tamper seal, the orifice reducer and the glass for cracks or leaks.
  2. Match the lot number on the bottle with the lot number on the GC/MS report.
  3. Read the Latin name, part, chemotype, origin and method against the product page.
  4. Smell one drop on a paper blotter, and set aside a bottle that smells flat, sour or of solvent.
  5. Write the opening date on the label, so the shelf life can be counted.

Two findings are normal. Crystals in peppermint, rose otto or anise oil after a cold delivery are menthol, stearoptenes or anethole, and they melt in a warm hand. Colour varies by oil, from the deep blue of German chamomile to the amber of patchouli. The peaks and percentages to read in step 2 are explained in the guide to reading a batch GC/MS report.

How should you store essential oils after you buy them?

You store essential oils after you buy them below 25 °C (77 °F), in amber or cobalt glass, tightly capped and out of the light, with citrus and conifer oils in a refrigerator at 2 °C to 8 °C (36 °F to 46 °F). Storage sets how long the purchase lasts. Unopened cold-pressed citrus and conifer oils keep 1 to 2 years from distillation, most distilled oils 2 to 3 years, and sandalwood, patchouli and vetiver 4 years or more. Decanting a half-used bottle into a smaller one shrinks the air above the oil and slows oxidation. The 8 rules for light, temperature, air and caps are set out in the essential oil storage rules.

How does the buyer's checklist relate to the purity checks?

The buyer's checklist wraps the 9 purity checks in the purchase, because the purity checks test whether one bottle is pure and the checklist adds the choice of oil, the size, the price per mL and storage around them. The label checks and the report checks appear in both lists. The 9 checks, with the 3 home tests that do not work, are set out in the guide that shows how to test an oil for purity by evidence rather than by label claims. A buyer who runs both lists ends with an oil that is pure, suited to its user and fairly priced.

Pure single essential oils from Miracle Botanicals

Miracle Botanicals sells about 200 single essential oils, each one steam-distilled, cold-pressed or CO2-extracted and tested by a third-party laboratory with GC/MS. Every product page names the Latin name, the plant part, the chemotype where one exists, the country of origin and the extraction method, and the GC/MS report for the batch is available on request. Miracle Botanicals is based in Hawaii and distils a small number of island oils and hydrosols. Browse the single essential oils collection to run the checklist on any oil, from the label facts to the batch report.

Hope Johnson, founder of Miracle Botanicals

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Hope Johnson

Founder, Miracle Botanicals

Hope Johnson founded Miracle Botanicals with her family in Hawaiʻi in 2011. She shares her experience with essential oils and aromatic rituals through the journal and continues to support the family business as a consultant.

Read more about author

KEEP EXPLORING

Related articles

LET’S STAY CONNECTED

A little inspiration, delivered.

Subscribe to get special offers, free giveaways, and once-in-a-lifetime deals.

Read our Privacy Policy.